Why Does My Homemade Yogurt Taste Like Cheese. The key to having your Greek style cream cheese taste as good as possible is to make sure that you have bought a type of plain Greek yogurt that does not have a sharp taste to it. If you make buttermilk and cultured butter make yogurt or cheese the lactose is converted to lactic acid by bacteria and is no longer a sugar but tastes acidic.
Some brands of Greek Yogurt are kinda tangy and to me that is a turn-off Id rather eat the fattening stuff then to get that yucky zing taste in my. To lessen the cheese taste go buy a cheap stab blender if you dont have one already or use a normal blender. Nothing funny looking no discoloration mold separation nothing.
The result is a half-cheese half-yogurt that tastes like cheese and smells like yogurt.
Our CSA sells locally-made organic. By Sawsan Abu FarhaMay 11 201210 mins to read. There are so many factors involved which means no two ferments will be exactly the same. I like it but more sour than most plain greek yogurt.